The Hind Gut Acidity Bandwagon is Dangerous

It’s the trendy diagnosis.  Hind gut acidity, sometimes used synonymously with hind gut ulcers, is blamed for a staggering array of signs ranging from poor appetite to cracked hooves to right hind lameness and any undesirable behavior trait you can mention.  It’s bad enough that there is virtually no scientific justification for most of this.  Worse yet is that the treatments suggested could be harmful.

enterolith

                          Enteroliths are stones that form inside the intestinal tract.

Enteroliths are stones that form inside the intestines when minerals precipitate around a core of nondigestible material.  The core could be things like a wood fragment, piece of string or bit of rubber fencing.  Most enteroliths are composed of struvite – magnesium ammonium phosphate.

Several factors have been identified as risks for enterolith formation.  High intake of magnesium, phosphorus or protein is certainly one.  The ammonium forms from bacterial breakdown of protein.  Risk factors can vary between cases but one universal finding is an alkaline environment in the large intestine.  If you are feeding your horse a product to increase pH/reduce acidity in the large intestine you are increasing the risk of enterolith formation – especially if the horse didn’t need it in the first place.  A mildly acidic pH in the high 6’s is normal for the cecum.

What if the horse doesn’t have an acidity problem and the supplement makes it’s hind gut more alkaline than normal – is more better?  No.  The intestinal milieu is a very complex network with many different species of organisms interacting synergistically in an environment where their food sources and pH requirements are compatible.  If you artificially change the environment, some species will die and fermentation will suffer.

Some people are advised to feed their horse the drug ranitidine to control hind gut acidity, allegedly because it works better than omeprazole for the hind gut. Both of those drugs reduce stomach acid.  Since there are no acid secreting cells in the hind gut, there is no reason to think either one would help.  It is normal for the stomach to be extremely acidic. The horse’s body takes care of this by secreting very large amounts of bicarbonate into the small intestine.

The system is so effective pH goes from an acidic low of 2 in the stomach to the mid to high 6’s in the small intestine.  The body makes all the bicarbonate it needs from an endless supply of water and carbon dioxide.  To look at any proposed role of stomach acid in hind gut ulcers another way, why wouldn’t you see ulcers showing up in large numbers and greater severity in the small intestine which is exposed to stomach contents before they even reach the hind gut?  There is no mention of small intestinal ulcers in the postmortem dissections.

Is there a problem with reducing the load of stomach acid just in case?  Yes, there is. Stomach acid is there for a reason.  It is the first line of defense against intestinal infections.  It activates an enzyme that starts protein digestion in the stomach.  Stomach acid is also needed to break supplemental minerals into their ionic form so they can be absorbed.

Treating a condition that does not exist can be harmful.  If you are concerned about hind gut acidity, ask your vet to test fecal pH first.  Between 6.2 and 6.5 is the usual range.

Eleanor Kellon, VMD

 

About Dr. Kellon

Graduate of University of Pennsylvania Veterinary School. Owner of Equine Nutritional Solutions, www.drkellon.com, industry and private nutritional consultations, online nutritional courses. Staff Veterinary Expert at Uckele Health and Nutrition.
This entry was posted in Equine Nutrition and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to The Hind Gut Acidity Bandwagon is Dangerous

  1. journey5956 says:

    How does Equishure factor into this? Can it neutralize too much? Is there a way to determine if Equishure helps or is needed?

  2. Patrice Sager says:

    IN light of this article let me add in some thoughts. We in our society are a bit influenced by TV adds. So lets say that we may have been trained to believe that antiacids for humans are a must and that when the stomach burns or we think we have acid indigestion, for humans, we assume it is high acid. But what if it is low acid that is the problem and we then take an antiacid? We just created a bigger problem. And what if we transfer the mind set to our horses that because they have highly acidic stomachs that we the owner somehow must give them relief? And it is my opinion that we are adding more problems then we are fixing by throwing antiacids at them. I agree with this article in that we better know that horse needs something before we blindly throw it at them.

  3. Joe Sibiski says:

    Dr. Kellon, I have been giving one ounce of apple cider vinegar to our mare to prevent enteroliths. Is it needed?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s